JapanProbe Friends - Featured Members


Noriko Calderon’s parents leave Japan

April 14th, 2009 by James


Sarah and Arlan Calderon, illegal immigrants from the Philippines who had hoped the Japanese government would grand them residency visas because their daughter was born in Japan, left the country yesterday after losing their fight against a deportation order:

Meanwhile, Noriko, who has been entrusted to the care of Sarah’s younger sister, said that she is anxious about her life as a whole and school “because it is my first time living apart from my parents.”

“I won’t be able to eat the delicious food my mother cooks,” she said, adding that her parents are “irreplaceable.”

“But it’s not like we’re never going to see each other,” said the teenager, who recently became a second-year student at a junior high school in Warabi, Saitama Prefecture. “I hope I can show them (the next time we meet) that I do my best.”

Earlier in the day, relatives and Arlan’s colleagues gathered at the family’s home in Warabi to bid farewell to the couple.

“We will be waiting for you (to come back),” said construction worker Yasuhisa Nagashima, one of Arlan’s colleagues, adding that it would not be “goodbye.”

Arlan hugged each of his colleagues and thanked them for their kindness.

“Noriko is here, so I hope we can return to her side as soon as possible,” Arlan said, adding that he hoped the day would come when the family would “be able to live quietly together in Japan.”

A fund set up to help provide money for Noriko’s living and educational expenses has already raised 1.58 million yen.

Update: CNN’s Kyung Lah has filed a report about the story:

Noriko Calderon, wearing her school uniform, was being forced to make one of the most wrenching choices of her young life: To stay in the country of her birth rather than join her parents being deported to the Philippines.

The scene was the emotional climax to a story a decade and a half in the making — one that has tugged at heartstrings in Japan, but ultimately failed to sway to an unyielding bureaucracy that activists say violates human rights.

Seeing as the Japanese government didn’t immediately deport them in 2006 and let them remain in the country and plead their case until a special exception was made to permit Noriko to stay in Japan, I hardly see how it is fair to declare that the bureaucracy was “unyielding.” Lah also uses the headline “Schoolgirl told to choose: Country or parents,” when it is clearly Noriko’s parents who had to make the decision of whether to bring their child back to the Philippines.

[hat tip to Keeping Pace in Japan]



Related Posts:
 

Noriko Calderon’s parents to be deported

Noriko Calderon to stay in Japan

Japanese government may grant Noriko Calderon special permission for residence

Update on Noriko Calderon

Amnesty International comments on the Noriko Calderon case


RSS feed

32 Comments »

Comment by Rated-R
2009-04-14 07:59:05

Good riddance!

Comment by Redalert
2009-04-14 21:33:08

We don’t want them here either.

Comment by Makoto Shimizu
2009-04-19 05:47:26

I thank God for Japan that has been a blessed country which blesses many countries. Thanks to God because my father came as an immigrant to Brazil. The earth seem from the space has no borders, let´s make the world a place of peace and love and solidarity to all to live in freedom.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
 
 
Comment by Simon
2009-04-14 09:33:48

Rated-R, that’s a bit harsh isn’t it?
Regardless of what you think about the Calderons or their actions, you can’t argue that they were _harming_ society (or you) by being here.

 
Comment by Bradley
2009-04-14 09:47:34

I’m glad the girl got to stay in Japan. At least she’ll be able to complete her education and live a somewhat normal life. It would’ve been a shame if she’d been deported. How could she have even gone to school in the Philippines if she speaks no Tagalog?

Comment by dA
2009-04-14 12:02:19

also how could she survive in a country that crappy? The very same reason her parents left that country in the first place.

Also please note, I am from Malaysia and have been to philipines so I’m not being a racist or anything. But I know what kind of hardship they will have to go through.

Comment by Redalert
2009-04-14 21:12:54

We survived here in the Philippines with the poverty and even though we all view Japan as one of the most prosperous country in the world, that’s no excuse for opportunist Filipinos to stay ILLEGALLY there. Knowing Japan and their strict laws (been there as a tourist) I didn’t expect Japan would grant them residence because that would be a very bad precedent and like they said, will undermine their immigration laws if they took exception.

It’s a shame what the parents did. Seeing Japan as their home country and denouncing Philippines as their true homeland when they just entered there illegally and work. Their daughter is just a victim here.

And dA, you ask us how could she survived here in a country so crappy. Sure our country is poor but getting past poverty it all depends on the people. We started from almost nothing and now we are fairly affluent. And I don’t thing those couple with all the years illegaly working there are deprived of a headstart and opportunities to make good here.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
Comment by koan
2009-04-15 03:25:08

That “crappy country” is the only country she’s ever known. She has a lot of support from friends and local people so it’s not as terrible for her as it could be, although it does seem quite harsh.

I’m sure she has changed her opinion of her home country since the action to force her out started.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by dA
2009-04-15 10:19:26

When I said that crappy country, I was referring to Philipines, not Japan

 
 
 
 
Comment by dobokun
2009-04-14 13:04:45

残念だな。もうすかして、できるを誰だ。

 
Comment by dobokun
2009-04-14 13:14:23

this does happen though in many instance and they did break law.

 
Comment by Turner Wright
2009-04-14 14:14:08

True – that CNN report makes it appear as though they just jumped on the issue, when it’s been going on for over two years; notice how the stress “gainfully employed” when he couldn’t be… not with an illegal entry.

I feel bad their daughter has been put in this situation but the blame lies with them, and they know it – they took a gamble coming into the country without a valid work visa, and now, it’s not paying off. They should be prepared for consequences as such.

 
Comment by Ikunochan
2009-04-14 14:27:43

I agree that it was wrong to have broken immigration laws, and unfortunately, the parents now have to suffer the consequences of having broken the law. It’s terribly sad, however, that their daughter will now have to be without her parents during her teen years. This wasn’t Noriko’s fault, and I feel for her. If anything, the parents piss me off for taking such a gamble. They had to know that something like this may happen sooner or later. Why didn’t they care about how this might affect their daughter?

True that she may well be much better off with the opportunity to stay and finish her education in Japan, but I doubt she’s thinking much about that right now. I hope that the home of the relative she is staying with is at least stable and enough of a comfort to help her get through this tough time.

 
Comment by David
2009-04-14 14:39:40

It’s unyielding because it’s a bureaucracy that cares only about laws and not about persons. And it’s not only a parent’s decision, it’s a family decision. Something i suppose they decided talking between the three of them. If you don’t care about what your children thinks :-( , i feel sorry for your children. Noriko’s parents seem to value her opinion.

Comment by ponta
2009-04-15 07:42:40

“Japan is my homeland,” Noriko told CNN when asked why she decided to stay behind when her parents were deported.
Her parents say her life will be better in Japan than the poor farming community where they will be living in the Philippines.
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/asia-pacific/7998048.stm

 
 
Comment by Alex
2009-04-14 16:53:36

Justice trumps compassion once more! Huzzah! Long live cold-hard justice in a world where people do bad things because, “there’s no law against it”, and don’t do good things because there is a law against it!

 
Comment by weirdo
2009-04-14 17:19:55

CNNひでぇ~w

 
Comment by hoihoi
2009-04-14 17:28:57

The Department of Foreign Affairs (DFA) has committed to extend “humanitarian assistance” to a Filipino couple who were asked to leave Japan due to illegal staying, a diplomatic source said.

“The DFA officials expressed readiness to send humanitarian assistance to the Filipino couple and their daughter should they decide to go back to the Philippines,” the source said. Japan threatened to deport Arlan and Sarah Calderon who were discovered to have entered Japan with fake passports almost 17 years ago.

The assistance, the source said, includes services provided by the Department of Social Welfare and Development (DSWD) to help the child adjust in her new home, he said.

The source said the Philippine government couldn’t give in to the couple’s request to remain in Japan because it would only send the wrong signal to the international community. “What can we do? They’re asking to stay in Japan. Does it mean that they don’t want to stay in the Philippines?” he asked.

The signal that the Calderon family is giving to the world is “Phillippines suck”.

http://mb.com.ph/node/198570

Comment by Alex
2009-04-14 18:16:37

Yeah, it’s SOOOOOO easy. All you have to do is slip into the country, give birth to a child, and enroll them in 7 years of primary school education while working jobs under the table. I can already see illegal family-planning criminal rings starting to emerge!

 
Comment by Redalert
2009-04-14 21:29:15

Yes, that’s a clear signal and we all felt bad denouncing his homeland for YEN. I felt really bad that watching them in the news insisting “being japanese” even when they got back here, speaking only in nihongo and speaking exclusively to Japanese media.

And the government planning to help these japanese wannabes, that’s pure sucks.

Philippines is not that bad, I have relatives here who married Japanese and the japanese father allowed her daughter and son to grow up here.

 
 
Comment by ponta
2009-04-14 20:12:10

Is CNN’s report correct?
Have the parents already asked for the special landing permission?

夫妻はマニラ市内に住んで仕事を探す。再来日の時期は未定という。
Her parents will return to Manila to look for work. The date of their next visit to Japan has yet to be decided.

本来、退去強制で帰国した場合、5年間は再入国できない。だが森英介法相は、子供に会うための短期滞在であれば、帰国後1年たたなくても、両親に上陸特別許可を出す柔軟な姿勢を明らかにしている。
Deportation usually carries with it a five-year ban on re-entering the country. However, Justice Minister Eisuke Mori said that he will grant special landing permission to Arlan and Sarah in order to see their daughter.

http://mdn.mainichi.jp/mdnnews/news/20090414p2a00m0na017000c.html

同省は、1年前後で夫妻に上陸特別許可を与え、短期間、会うことを認める方針だ。

(2009年4月13日19時39分 読売新聞)

 
Comment by Aceface
2009-04-14 23:56:31

They can probably come into Japan to see their daughter,but probably difficult to get working permit.

You know it’s just ain’t fair,because we are allowing so many Zainichi Koreans coming here illegaly and get special status and give them opportunity and some may even become Japanese national and 22nd richiest man in the country and also decorated by Orders of the Sacred Treasure by emperor,but you get kicked out if you are Phillipino?

http://ja.wikipedia.org/wiki/韓昌祐

Kyung Lah should think twice about using “unyielding bureaucracy”.

 
Comment by Patty
2009-04-15 02:07:47

Again, what a load of crock. I feel badly for Noriko who has to live with the consequences of her parents’ actions. However, the situation is not as dire as the media makes it out to be. She’ll be living with her aunt, that’s not exactly the same as being orphaned or being thrown out onto the street. And secondly, this whole mess would not have started if the parents didn’t use Noriko as pawn to continue their illegal stay in Japan. The fact that Noriko does not speak Filipino is not an issue either since there are a number of excellent Japanese schools complete with, whoa, wait for it, kids who only speak Japanese! I wish Noriko the best of luck and hope that this is the last we hear of the reprehensible parents.

 
Comment by ini
2009-04-15 03:44:23

so, Noriko is paying for her parents failed gamble. Fine, I’m glad she at least managed to stay. Deporting her would probably mean a death penalty

 
Comment by mochi
2009-04-15 05:27:12

Why did they leave their daughter? Is that a ploy to regain entry in Japan? They should have taken the child and let her live the Filipino way. After all, she IS a Filipino. She can speak Japanese and might probably look Japanese, but the blood running through her veins are 100% Pinoy. Come on, girl! Be proud of your heritage! Life goes on, whether you’re in the Philippines, or Japan.

 
Comment by Kevin C.
2009-04-15 15:33:08

Fucking Japanese…. That’s all I can say. My heart goes out to that girl and her family. Unbelievable.

Comment by LB
2009-04-15 18:55:16

How about “F’in’ illegal immigrants” – that is about all that REALLY can or needs to be said.

 
 
Comment by Emily
2009-04-15 16:03:37

What I don’t like in this situation is that the parents let their child believed that she is pure Japanese. The fact that the kid only speaks Japanese is one of the main reasons why they are separated (in my own opinion).

If the girl can speak Filipino even just a little bit, she can go with her parents to the Philippines.

I really don’t like it when Filipinos who live in other countries who speak Filipino would raise their children not knowing any Filipino at all.

 
Comment by Ken Y-N
2009-04-15 23:34:13

Looking at the video of the protestors, the question that hasn’t been asked yet is, would these conservative protesters have the balls to do this to a 13-year-old girl if she were Japanese? Somehow I doubt it. I think they’re expecting to get away with their (in my view heartless) invective just because Noriko’s foreign.

Comment by Aceface
2009-04-16 12:27:30

Well,if she were a Japanese,then there is no problem in the first place,No?

But yes,these “protesters” has no heart nor guts.

 
 
Comment by Makoto Shimizu
2009-04-19 05:54:49

I thank God for Japan that has been a blessed country which blesses many countries. Thanks to God because my father came as an immigrant to Brazil. The earth seem from the space has no borders, let´s make the world a place of peace and love and solidarity to all to live in freedom. Japan will become a World Leader by giving example of a generous country, human driven country. Acts of love and solidarity will be never forgiven. Japan will play a new role as a leader in a changing world by opening its doors to the world in hunger and poverty. Japan is more than technology, Japan has good brains and good hearts, hearts of flesh. Japan will be known as a country of kindness and mercy and deep concern for building a new world, for making the earth a better place to live for now and the future.

 
Comment by Jesa
2009-04-25 02:11:29

I feel sorry for Noriko for suffering for her parents bad gamble. I am more angry at the parents for choosing such a stupid path.

 
Name (required)
E-mail (required - never shown publicly)
URI
Your Comment (smaller size | larger size)
You may use <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong> in your comment. (Please close your HTML tags.)

If your comment isn't showing up, it's probably stuck in the spam filter or in moderation. Instead of typing the same comment over and over and sending it, contact us. Most comments are visible within a few minutes of their posting.
This site is not an open forum: we have rules. Read our discussion policy for more details.

Trackback responses to this post