Sword Smith Wants Scenes Deleted From ‘Yasukuni’ Documentary
Li Ying, director of ‘Yasukuni,’ a documentary that takes a critical look at the shrine in Tokyo that honors Japan’s war dead, has told the press that he suspects political meddling is behind the Yasukuni sword smith Naoji Kariya’s reported desire to have scenes removed from the film:
In a news conference Thursday, director Li Ying said the 90-year-old sword smith in the documentary had accepted how he appeared in the film and even expressed hope for the documentary’s success.
Li said he showed the documentary to the sword smith, the last maker of Yasukuni swords, and his wife in spring last year. Li said he also explained to the sword smith the significance of the movie and the controversy surrounding Yasukuni Shrine, which honors Class-A war criminals along with the nation’s war dead and is viewed among other Asian countries as a symbol of Japan’s aggression before and during World War II.
“The deletion of the master’s scenes will cripple this movie, and I wonder what the lawmaker told him and if (a Diet member) is allowed to use his or her authority to change a character’s mind,” the director said.
[...]In an interview Thursday with The Asahi Shimbun, the sword smith and his 83-year-old wife, who live in Kochi Prefecture, said they received a written request from Li in 2005 to use him in the documentary.
The man said he allowed Li to film him while he was producing the last Yasukuni sword.
After the film was completed, Li visited the man’s residence to show him the movie, but the man said he asked Li to remove his footage and name because they were used “in manners far from” what he thought the director had intended.
The sword smith said he was surprised to see his scenes mixed with highly charged political images, including former Prime Minister Junichiro Koizumi’s visits to the shrine in Tokyo and the protests against those pilgrimages.
The sword smith acknowledged that he was contacted by lawmaker Arimura in late March and Wednesday because she wanted to hear his opinion on the documentary. He said he told Arimura that the movie is “far from his intention” and that he wants his appearance and name removed.
“I thought the film was aimed at showing future generations the traditional techniques and artistic value of Yasukuni swords, and I never expected it to be used in a direct connection with the Yasukuni controversy,” the sword smith said.
Negative publicity has caused several Tokyo theaters to cancel previously scheduled screenings of the film. However, 21 cinemas around the country are still planning to show the film in May (assuming that the footage of Kariya remains in the film).
Update: This video on YouTube contains an interview with the sword smith. About 7 minutes into the clip, he is asked to comment on the documentary. He reads a prepared statement similar to what he told the Asahi Shinbun. Other videos in the same series include an interview with Tom Kishida, author of The Yasukuni Swords: Rare Weapons of Japan, who also claims the makers of ‘Yasukuni’ told him they were making a non-political film about sword making when obtaining his consent to an interview.


I think that the Yi Ling misguided sword smith and is now using this situation to further add critisium toward Japan. I think what the Sword smith said to Asahi is true and that this was not his intention. I don’t think the director is telling the complete truth.
Rate this comment:
0
0
Let’s just shut up and not criticise the movie until we’ve actually SEEN it!
I hope Li will simply release it online soon so that everyone can make their minds up for themselves.
Rate this comment:
0
0
ummm, I don’t think anyone or text here is criticising this movie. we are just “discussing” what the comments have been towrd a recent article in the newspaper. We have yet to try to critique the movie so there is no need for you to say “shut up.” I may have critizied the director but not the movie. . .yet.
Rate this comment:
0
0
Have you seen the real movie yet? I saw it at a Movie Festival in Germany.
At the beginning I thought the smith wasn’t aware of how he was used in the movie. But after some time you notice his determination to make the movie as authentic as possible. He keeps quiet when he doesn’t want to talk and that convinces me that all his statements are how he feels. You can feel what he feels at some point in the movie.
The statement in the newspaper seems to be a reaction to “important” people “talking” to him. (Especially old) Japanese seek harmony. So in the end he listens to the politicans and decides to give in to the request for the sake of the “Japanese Nation”.
In the end the only message you get from the swordsmith within the movie is: “War is wrong.”
Rate this comment:
0
0
Having been reading about how Richard Dawkins and others were duped into appearing in “Expelled,” and knowing the pressure brought to bear over the NHK Comfort Women thing, I would say both are likely.
Rate this comment:
0
0
Yeah it’s kind of suspicious of how late this has been brought up, since he did mention having seen the movie soon after completion. I reiterate the comment of some upper powers ‘influencing’ him, probably threatened to stab him in the leg or something. (urgh…I’m being influenced myself by another to say this D:)
Rate this comment:
0
0
How unwittingly asinine do you have to be to make this kind of propaganda film? It’s a shrine, and while it does harbor war-criminals, it is still a shrine. Do these people know no bounds when it comes to hate-filled rhetoric, and times past?
If more people stopped sulking with pictures, they would look to the future as an opportunity to improve. Those who dwindle in history, become history.
Rate this comment:
0
0
Well, whatever country you guys are from, watch out for ‘Chinese Trojan Horse’ in your home country. Don’t you remember that the POW needed to go through batteries of debriefing after the POW’s in North Vietnam for long were finally extricated from the country.
Brainwashing has long term effect. Those Chinese coming out of that country are people who are born, “educated” and well brainwashed and seasoned. I am concerned to see more Chinese coming in my country without any treatment. More so after I heard about those Chinese from the Red China the way they behaved in San Francisco for the Olympics torch relay.
Rate this comment:
0
0